Statute of limitations to serve Civil Service Law Section 75 disciplinary charges extended where charges would constitute a crime
Mieles v Safir, 272 AD2d 199
The Mieles case provides an example of the application of the exception to statute of limitations set out in Section 75.4 of the Civil Service Law. Section 75.4 provides that the relevant statute of limitations for bringing disciplinary action does not apply where the incompetency or misconduct alleged would, if proved in a court of appropriate jurisdiction, constitute a crime.
Manuel Mieles, a New York City police officer, was dismissed from his position after being found guilty of having used false pretenses to trick the owner of a broken-down vehicle into giving him the title to the vehicle. Mieles then moved the vehicle from the street and sold it to a salvage company.
The department charge Mieles with unauthorized exercise of his official functions, in violation of Section 104-01, page 3, paragraph 4 of the Police Department Patrol Guide’s prohibition against conduct prejudicial to good order, efficiency or discipline of the department.
Mieles appealed his termination. One of the grounds he contended supported vacating the disciplinary action was that the charges filed against him were untimely as they were barred by the 18-month Statute of Limitations in Civil Service Law Section 75(4). The Appellate Division, First Department dismissed Mieles’ appeal.
The court said that [t]here is no merit to [Mieles’] argument that the charges filed against him were barred by Section 75.4’s 18-month Statute of Limitations. As the court explained, “the misconduct charged also constituted the crime of official misconduct under Section 195.00[1] of the Penal Law. Accordingly, Mieles was charged with, and found guilty of, acts of misconduct that were expressly excluded from the time bar of Section 75(4)....”
============================================
If you are interested in learning more about disciplinary procedures involving public officers and employees, please click here: http://thedisciplinebook.blogspot.com/
============================================