July 05, 2012

Destruction or loss of evidence


Destruction or loss of evidence
Dep't of Correction v. Archibald, OATH Index Nos. 2214/08, 2215/08 & 2216/08

OATH Administrative Law Judge John Spooner rejected a correction officer's motion to dismiss disciplinary charges filed againsthim based upon the spoliation of certain logbooks sought as evidence. Explaining that under New York law, sanctions for spoliation of evidence are appropriate where a litigant intentionally or negligently disposes of crucial evidence before the adversary has an opportunity to inspect them, the ALJ concluded that the officer failed to establish how the logbooks disappeared or how their disappearance would prejudice his defense.