If two workers get involved in a physical confrontation, must the employer mete out the same disciplinary penalty to each?
A technician [Technician] and her superior, a Team Leader, [Leader] were pointing their fingers at each other, presumably to emphasize points that they were making. When Leader grabbed Technician 's finger, Technician responded by slapping Leader.
The Employer dismissed the Technician. Technician sued, complaining that her termination constituted "discriminatory disciplinary action" because Leader had not been terminated as well.
The Circuit Court rejected Technician 's theory, commenting that Employer was not required to treat each "escalation" of the confrontation - finger pointing to finger grabbing to slapping - the same. In addition, the Court said another factor was that the two employees did not hold positions of similar rank. The decision by the Eighth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals also indicates that while Leader "had a spotless disciplinary record, Technician had a record of disciplinary problems."
The court upheld Technician's dismissal, commenting that the respective actions by Leader and Technician "are clearly differentiated because the incident involved two separate levels of escalation" ranging from the mutual pointing of fingers to a slap in retaliation for the grabbing of the finger.
The decision is posted on the Internet at: