Effort to have a court annul d resignation voluntarily submitted by an employee fails

Petitioner appealed Supreme Court's denial of his CPLR Article 78 petition to annul and rescind Petitioner's resignation from his probationary police officer position with the Metropolitan Transportation Authority [MTA]. The Appellate Division unanimously affirmed the lower court's ruling.

The Appellate Division said Supreme Court "correctly concluded that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction because the termination of [Petitioner's] employment was accomplished by his voluntary resignation rather than an administrative determination." The Appellate Division noted that the record indicated that Petitioner's resignation "was voluntary based on his desire to improve his chances of reinstatement in the future".

The court also held that Petitioner's claim of bias based on his ethnicity was unsupported by evidence in the record and he failed to present anything that indicated his termination was based on his ethnicity or any bias by the Field Training Officers who rated his performance as a probationary employee.

The Appellate Division opined that even had Petitioner's resignation not been voluntary, he failed to present evidence showing that his separation of his employment by MTA was arbitrary and capricious, an abuse of discretion, in bad faith, or violative of law and procedure as Petitioner's "performance in phases 2 and 3, and the remedial training phase was found below expectations and unacceptable by different Field Training Officers".

Smith v Kunkel,* is case involving an individual's seeking to have a court consider his efforts to withdraw his written resignation prior to its effective date.

Smith had submitted his resignation to the employer indicating that he was doing so for "personal reasons." The resignation was dated August 21 and was to take effect the September 3, next following. On August 29 Smith wrote Kunkel, the agency's Administrative Officer, "seeking to withdraw and rescind" his resignation. Kunkel declined to approve Smith’s request to withdraw his resignation, citing 4 NYCRR5.3(c)** of the rules for the classified service for employees of the State of New York as the Employer. 

Smith sued the agency contending that Kunkel's refusal to permit him to withdraw his resignation was arbitrary and capricious and that 4 NYCRR 5.3(c) was unconstitutional as it deprived him of his public employment without notice and hearing.

Addressing Smith's constitutional challenge to 4 NYCRR 5.3(c), the Appellate Division rejected Smith's argument noting his contention overlooked a crucial fact -- Smith had not been terminated by the appointing authority but rather had voluntarily resigned from his position. 

The court indicated that the "voluntariness of [Smith's] resignation is not vitiated by the fact that Kunkel rejected his withdrawal request prior to the effective date of his resignation." The Appellate Division concluded that Smith, having by his own action relinquished his position, did not retain any constitutionally protected property interest in it.

* 152 AD2d 893, appeal dismissed, 74 NY 2d 944.

** Said rules "apply to positions and employments in the classified service of the State and public authorities, public benefit corporations and other agencies for which the Civil Service Law is administered by the State Department of Civil Service". Many municipal civil service agencies in New York State have adopted a similar rule or regulation applicable to individuals subject to the municipal agency's jurisdiction.

Click HERE to access the Appellate Division's MTA decision posted on the Internet.

New York State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli announced the municipal audits listed below have been issued

On January 31, 2025 New York State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli announced the municipal audits listed below have been issued. 

Click on the text highlighted in color to access the item posted on the Internet 

Rensselaer County Industrial Development Agency (RCIDA) – Payments in Lieu of Taxes (2021M-74)

Officials did not ensure all PILOT agreements were properly billed, collected and distributed. Sixteen of the 62 bills reviewed were inaccurate because the county’s director of real property tax either used incorrect assessment values or tax rates and had an inconsistent payment calculation process that resulted in two projects being overbilled a total of $170,842 and two projects being underbilled a total of $184,474. Auditors also found that two taxing jurisdictions received $10,607 more than they should have while five others did not receive $24,239 that they should have.

 

Fairview Fire District – Payroll and Leave Accruals (Dutchess County)

District officials did not ensure all employee payroll payments and leave accruals were accurate, monitored, properly approved and supported. This occurred because the board did not provide adequate oversight, segregate payroll duties or develop compensating controls or develop written policies and procedures for these duties. As a result, auditors determined that district officials made payroll calculation errors totaling $8,936 and potentially overpaid 11 employees by a total of $44,301 for leave accrual payments. Officials also paid five employees $55,407 in overtime payments that could have been avoided or reduced.

 

Town of Chesterfield – Town Clerk (Essex County)

The clerk did not properly record, deposit, remit or report collections. As a result, officials do not have assurance that all collections are accounted for, and money could be lost or misappropriated. The clerk and deputy clerk did not record and issue receipts for collections totaling $18,289 received for 273 of 805 fees (34%). The clerk also did not prepare accurate monthly reports and remit collections to the supervisor and other agencies or prepare monthly bank reconciliations and accountability analyses which compare the amount of cash on hand and on deposit in the bank to detailed lists of amounts due to the supervisor and other agencies. Had the town board fulfilled its fiscal oversight responsibilities by conducting a thorough annual audit of the clerk’s records, the deficiencies identified may have been detected and addressed sooner.

 

Village of Washingtonville – Budget Review (Orange County)

The scope of the review was significantly limited by the lack of complete, accurate and current accounting records maintained by the village. The village could face a shortfall of approximately $261,000 in sewer rents and $123,000 in water rents if revenues are not realized. The 2025-26 tentative budget includes appropriations for personnel services of $3.3 million for general, water and sewer funds combined, but it could have additional expenditures when the village settles the police department’s expired collective bargaining agreement. Auditors also project the village is underestimating personnel services by approximately $21,000 for the water and sewer funds. The budget includes appropriations of approximately $243,400 for social security payments which are likely underestimated by approximately $21,200. The village has also underestimated health insurance payments for at least the last two fiscal years. The budget includes a $75,000 general fund contingency, which is less than 1% of the village’s general fund budgeted appropriations and a decrease of $25,000 from the 2024-25 adopted budget. During the review of the village’s proposed budget, auditors were provided with the village’s tentative budget 30 days before the scheduled vote, as required. However, the village posted a conflicting budget to its website six days later. As some of the differences between budgets were significant, such as a $32,471 difference in real property taxes, auditors chose to rely on the proposed budget that was posted to the village's website, as that was the version presented to the public. By not providing accurate budgeted figures timely for the review, the village hinders auditors’ ability to examine the tentative budget and make recommendations to help improve the village’s financial condition. The budget includes a tax levy of $5.4 million. Similar to the revenue and expenditure estimates, the lack of complete, accurate, and current accounting and financial records precludes auditors from concluding on the village’s tax cap compliance.

 

###

 

 

 

A Reasonable Disciplinary Penalty Under the Circumstances

The text of this E-Book focuses on determining an appropriate disciplinary penalty to be imposed on an employee in the public service in instances where the employee has been found guilty of misconduct or incompetence. For more information click HERE.

Links to selected items focusing on govenmental operations posted on the Internet during the week ending January 31, 2025.

5 Firms to Test Travel Tech at Grand Rapids, Mich., Airport The technology companies will pilot new air travel solutions this winter at Gerald R. Ford International Airport. Funding comes from the Ford Launchpad for Innovative Technologies and Entrepreneurship. READ MORE

AI and Cloud Strategies for State and Local Agencies This guide explores how AI-powered tools and cloud infrastructure can help government agencies overcome the challenges of tight budgets and aging infrastructure. DOWNLOAD

AI Companions: Addressing The New Frontier of Kids' Screen Addiction and Online Harms Registration is now open for the the online symposium, which will be held on Tuesday, February 18, 12-2:30 p.m. U.S. Eastern Time. Registration information, the agenda and speakers' bios are available here.

AI for Public Finances: Keeping Data Safe as You Modernize [Feb 5, 2025] Join a live webinar exploring essential strategies for ensuring the integrity and security of AI-driven finance systems. REGISTER

AI, Cybersecurity Top NASCIO Federal Advocacy Priorities The National Association of State Chief Information Officers’ annual list aggregates pressing tech and security challenges states face. Input from CIOs and CISOs helps shape its content. READ MORE

An Experienced Lawmaker Takes Over as South Dakota Governor Larry Rhoden has been serving as Kristi Noem's lieutenant governor. He'll inherit a tougher budget environment than she had. READ MORE

An Idea That Never Quite Disappears: Taxing Wealth It could bring states a lot of revenue. But voters don’t like it, even though few of them would have to pay. READ MORE

ANNOUNCING CDG-NACo’s Digital Counties Survey 2025! The Center for Digital Government and National Association of Counties invite all U.S. counties to participate in the Digital Counties Survey. DIGITAL COUNTIES SURVEY ONLINE

Arizona Invests in Cyber, Workforce for Economic Growth As Arizona's recent economic growth has created new job market opportunities, the state has been supporting cybersecurity initiatives and collaborations to bolster evolving workforce needs. READ MORE

Brake Early for S.F. Speed Cameras Ahead, Campaign Warns Billboards from the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency and speed camera warning signs on freeway off-ramps and in bus shelters are intended to caution drivers as more than 50 of the devices arrive in March. READ MORE

Brash Legislator Seeks to Remake California GOP in Trump’s Image Longtime conservative activist Carl DeMaio won an Assembly seat last year, arguing the GOP must be more aggressive against Democratic policies. Some Republicans call him a self-promoter who can’t be trusted. READ MORE

Building Safe and Secure Government Workplaces Watch this on-demand webinar to explore how government teams can equip themselves to support the work environments that ensure everyone has the resources they need to participate effectively, safely and securely. WATCH NOW

California Bill Would Provide a Year of Mortgage Relief to Fire Victims The legislation would block foreclosures and allow homeowners who’ve suffered financially due to the L.A. fires to freeze payments without penalty. Several major lenders have already reached agreement with Gov. Gavin Newsom to provide voluntary relief. READ MORE

Chester County, Pa., Looks to Raise Awareness About Online Scams Pennsylvania state Rep. Chris Pielli, along with the Housing Authority of Chester County, recently held a free program educating people on how to spot and avoid frauds and scams that use technology. READ MORE

Colorado Sales and Use Tax System Updates Support Business The Colorado Department of Revenue has completed a project refreshing the state’s Sales and Use Tax System for an improved user experience. The work follows a mandate from state legislators in 2023. READ MORE

Concerns About AI Election Impacts Are Overblown (So Far) AI caused less damage through misinformation or election administration than predicted in 2024. New laws meant to combat political deepfakes, meanwhile, went largely unenforced. READ MORE

Connected Data for Public Projects [Feb 4, 2025] Join this live webinar where we'll explore how capturing, standardizing, and connecting data can empower public agencies to achieve greater cost control, project accuracy, and team alignment. REGISTER

Could AI Help Bust Medicaid Scammers? Minnesota May Find Out Minnesota’s governor wants to crack down on Medicaid fraud with the help of artificial intelligence. The idea comes at a time when much of the country is struggling to convict and recover money from Medicaid scammers. READ MORE

Cyber Incident Temporarily Halts Pa. Child Support Payments The matter, which has since been resolved, prevented an estimated 121,000 families from getting around $27 million in collective payments. The incident was contained and systems have been restored. READ MORE

Dashcam Technology Is Cutting Down on City’s Legal Fees Garbage trucks in Scottsdale, Ariz., were recently equipped with dashcams that offer a comprehensive view of operations inside and out. The results are helping exonerate the municipality from frivolous damage claims. READ MORE

E-Bikes’ Fate Could Go to Voters in Colorado Springs, Colo. The City Council is considering a proposed policy on electric bicycles that would classify them as a “non-motorized use” permissible on trails open to other bikes. Civic leaders, however, say residents should get to vote. READ MORE

Empowering Local Governments to Accelerate Economic Mobility A national partnership aims to help local governments deliver better results for their residents. Learn More

Federal Grant for Tiny, Lightweight EVs Could Be on Hold A project to explore use of the small, electric vehicles could be paused by a recent federal memo. Its funding source is a grant from the U.S. Joint Office of Energy and Transportation. READ MORE

GenAI in Courts: How Artificial Intelligence Improves Efficiency and Accuracy in Court Systems State and local court systems are strained. Even routine legal processes can overburden staff and delay crucial judicial processes. The right AI assistant can transform the way courts are run, letting legal staff focus on helping more people get justice quickly and reliably. DOWNLOAD

Georgia Approves New Rule to Charge Data Centers for Power Atlanta is one of the hottest places in the country for tech companies to build data centers, hulking warehouses filled with servers that power web services, cryptocurrency and artificial intelligence. READ MORE

Helping Local Governments Deliver Better Results for Their Residents A national partnership has the power to reach tens of thousands of government leaders. Learn More

How Alabama Made Tax Services More Accessible The Alabama Department of Revenue faced significant operational challenges with its legacy systems, which were not meeting evolving needs for scalability, security and efficiency. Learn how the agency decided to move to the cloud to address these challenges, and more. DOWNLOAD

How One School District Retains Its Young Teachers Finding ways to support teaching as a career, including training, innovation and community engagement, helped a Chicago-area district increase its retention rate by 23 percent in just three years. READ MORE

How Security Services Partnerships Protect K-12 Schools As cyberattacks on K-12 schools become more costly and disruptive, ensuring robust cybersecurity measures is critical. This paper provides an in-depth exploration of how security services partnerships can help schools effectively mitigate cyber risks, prevent ransomware attacks, and ensure continuity in education. DOWNLOAD

How to Enhance the Fire Service using the Latest Technology Discover how innovative technology can address the growing firefighter shortage by enhancing safety, streamlining training, and improving resource deployment. DOWNLOAD

Indiana House May Freeze Transportation Grants to Localities A bill would set caps on infrastructure funds, allowing localities to make up the difference by charging fees on deliveries. Local officials say the plan will leave them short. READ MORE

Is Your Organization Ready for the Big Event? Premium IMS Tools for Sporting Events/Mass Gatherings CONTINUE READING

Kansas Sees Largest U.S. Outbreak of Tuberculosis Since the 1950s Health officials are calling the outbreak of the highly contagious disease “unprecedented,” but the numbers remain small, with 67 active infections centered in the Kansas City suburbs. READ MORE

Manhattan Traffic Clears, Speeds Up in Congestion Pricing Zone Early data from the new congestion pricing project in Manhattan is showing increased vehicle speeds, a boon for bus riders and transit users, and an indication fees to enter the zone below 60th Street are having an impact. READ MORE

Maryland Bill Would Mandate Multifaceted Data Center Study A proposed bill in the Maryland General Assembly seeks to create an analysis and report about the economic, environmental and energy consequences of data center development in the state. READ MORE

Maryland Should Not Retreat from Its School Performance Plan Maryland took historic steps to improve its education system. It shouldn't back away from them now. READ MORE

Master Revenue Forecasting for Local Government Discover how Euna Budget Professional empowers local governments with predictive analytics, scenario planning, and revenue forecasting. LEARN MORE

Maximizing the Impact of On-Site Solar Energy for Local Governments Read about this comprehensive approach to on-site solar energy can catalyze local government transformation. READ MORE

Miami is Nearing the Finish Line for Its New 10-Mile Park Governing sat down with the former transportation chief now leading the effort to finish the linear park. READ MORE

Michigan Eliminates Work Requirements for Medicaid Recipients Gov. Gretchen Whitmer has signed a bill overturning the state’s work requirements, which had previously been blocked in court. The bill passed in December while Democrats still controlled the Legislature, with Republicans complaining it sent the wrong message to recipients. READ MORE

New ChatGPT Gov Enables Use of Non-Publicly Available Data ChatGPT Gov is the latest artificial intelligence tool from OpenAI, geared toward expanded use by government agencies, and offering another way to access advanced machine learning models. READ MORE

New Jersey Mystery Drones Were Authorized by Feds The White House said Tuesday the drones spotted flying over New Jersey late last year were authorized by the Federal Aviation Administration for “research and various other reasons.” READ MORE

Opexus Buys Casepoint and Wins Big PE Investment Thoma Bravo takes an ownership stake in Opexus. The seller of process management software plans to integrate Casepoint’s data management technology as Opexus works to gain more state and local clients. READ MORE

Pennsylvania Rejects Plan for Charter School Taught by AI The Department of Education denied an application from a cyber charter school that would have been part of a multistate network. Classes would have been led by AI tutors with humans serving as “guides.” READ MORE

Philadelphia Transit Agrees to Pay Additional $230 Million to Fix Fare System Since implementing an electronic fare card in 2016, the system has been plagued by glitches and doubled its projected cost to $285 million. READ MORE

Resilient HERoes podcast: Women in Emergency Management Showcasing the incredible journeys, and contributions of women in the field of emergency management. CONTINUE READING

Ridership Lulls and Autonomous Vehicles: How San Francisco Transit Fared The Last Five Years Jeffrey Tumlin oversaw the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency during a period of tumult for public transit and city streets. READ MORE

Secession Schemes Within the States Residents of red counties in blue states wish they had a new political home. Also, in Florida, the Legislature is starting to stand up to Ron DeSantis. READ MORE

See the Unseen: How Video Analytics Enhances Public Safety See how video analytics empowers public safety teams with real-time insights, helping to reduce crime, manage crowds, and ensure community safety. DOWNLOAD

Should a New City Make Hiring a Lobbyist One of Its Early Priorities? Crystal River, Minn., is a freshly incorporated city that lacks money for services and infrastructure. A lobbyist would help secure state funds, but some local officials call the idea a “racket.” READ MORE

Some Simple Ways to Make Government Work Appeal to IT Professionals Some programmers and engineers are willing to forego private-sector pay to find meaningful work. But governments need to be more nimble about hiring and provide better career paths. READ MORE

State of Oklahoma OMES Takes a Whole-of-State Approach Spearheading a “whole-of-state” approach to essential services, Oklahoma OMES strives to increase efficiency, reduce financial and administrative overheads, and eliminate the duplication of effort, making it easier for the state’s agencies and affiliates to focus on their core missions. READ MORE

States Work to Fight Disinformation During Emergencies Some officials are wondering what, if anything, state governments can do to stop the spread of harmful lies and rumors that proliferate on social media during emergency situations. READ MORE

Streamline Revenue Forecasting for Local Government Manage fiscal uncertainties, strengthen your agency’s strategy, and serve your community better with revenue forecasting. LEARN MORE

Surge in Immigrants Contributed to Rising Homeless Counts Homelessness rose last year by 18 percent, but much of the increase took place in a handful of states that had received lots of immigrants. Some experts say their increase during a HUD census inflated the actual numbers. READ MORE

Taking a Broad Approach to Digital Identity This thought leadership paper explains why states need to go beyond adopting mobile driver’s licenses (mDLs) to fully address digital identity and fraud. DOWNLOAD

Tennessee Legislature Poised to Pass School Voucher Bill The education committees in both the House and Senate approved a $450 million bill, a top priority for Gov. Bill Lee. Legislators are expected to pass it quickly during a special session this week. READ MORE

Texas Gov. Seeks $11 Billion Reimbursement for Border Security As the Trump administration steps up immigration enforcement, GOP Gov. Greg Abbott has sent a request to congressional leaders to be paid back for his Biden-era efforts. READ MORE

Texas Lawmakers File More Than 20 Bills to Roll Back Vaccine Mandates Enjoying momentum thanks to Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s nomination as federal health secretary, vaccine skeptics are pushing state-level bills to block mandates and give parents and workers greater latitude to opt out. READ MORE

Texas State Office Fires 7 Employees After Data Breach The personal identifying information of more than 61,000 Texans may have been compromised in a data breach, and some of the state's most vulnerable residents are at highest risk. READ MORE

The Marshall Plan We Need to Tackle Our Housing Crisis Cities across the country are committed to making it easier to build housing and are taking a variety of promising approaches, note the leaders of the U.S. Conference of Mayors. But they must be bolstered by federal investment and flexibility. READ MORE

The State of Digital Identity in Government Download this report for vital insights on the evolution of digital identity, fraud prevention and online service delivery in government. DOWNLOAD

Trump Executive Order Aims to Position U.S. as AI Leader A newly signed executive order from President Donald Trump aims to establish and secure the nation’s position as a leader in artificial intelligence. An AI Action Plan is slated to follow. READ MORE

Trump Signs Order Demanding California Move More Water The president noted the need to fight Los Angeles fires, but the water would go elsewhere in the state primarily to aid farmers. Environmentalists complained the move was unlawful. READ MORE  

U.S. Marines Test New Anti-Drone System in Hawaii Marines used their new hunter-killer system to blast dozens of target drones out of the sky Saturday over a training ground on the Big Island of Hawaii. READ MORE

Ulster, N.Y., Grapples With Aftermath of Ransomware Attack A hack in September [2024] continues to present issues around data loss and retrieval, and installation of a different bookkeeping system has been delayed. Officials were unable to determine who was behind the incident. READ MORE

What a Century-Old Planned Community Can Teach Us About Growth
John Nolen’s blueprint for Venice, Fla., is legendary among urban planners. But what's interesting about Venice as a place, as opposed to a plan, is how it’s evolved in real life. READ MORE

Workflow Automation Firm SimpliGov Wins Big Investment The company’s platform is used by state and local governments for such tasks as licensing, case management and procurement. JMI Equity, a growth equity firm, will get two seats on the company’s board. READ MORE

World Economic Forum 2025: Navigating Cybersecurity in an Era of Complexity What was the cyber outlook at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, this past week? From President Trump’s address to new white papers, here’s your roundup. READ MORE