Nov 20, 2026

New York City Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings [OATH] recently posted employee disciplinary decisions on the Internet

Excessive absence

OATH Administrative Law Judge [ALJ] Joycelyn McGeachy-Kuls recommended dismissal of an excessive absence charge against an eligibility specialist [Respondent]. 

The Employee [Respondent] did not deny that she was absent on the charged days but argued that her supervisor’s denial of her request to work remotely was unfair as her colleagues were approved to do so. 

The ALJ found that the Employer [Petitioner] proved that Respondent was absent without authorization on the charged occasions but did not establish that the absences were excessive per se because they were less than 50% of Respondent’s assigned workdays. Judge McGeachy-Kuls also found that Petitioner failed to prove that Respondent’s absences had an adverse effect on the operations of her department. 

Click HERE to access Judge McGeachy-Kuls' decision and recommendation.


Multiple motor vehicle violations

ALJ Julia Davis recommended termination of employment for a motor vehicle operator [Respondent] who incurred multiple motor vehicle violations. 

The Administrative Law Judge determined that Respondent committed misconduct by incurring eleven motor vehicle violations, including for operating his agency vehicle in a bus lane, proceeding through a red light, speeding in a school zone, driving recklessly, and pursuing another driver after a collision, as well as for absenting himself from his tour of duty. 

The ALJ rejected Respondent’s defense that the charges were brought in retaliation for Respondent filing complaints against a supervisor, as there was a clear and independent basis for each of the charges. 

In assessing the appropriate penalty, Judge Davis found that Respondent’s alleged ignorance of certain traffic laws, lack of a prior disciplinary history, and the extra work he performed during the COVID-19 pandemic was insufficient to outweigh Respondent’s long history of violations and his failure to correct his conduct despite multiple warnings. 

Click HERE to access Judge Davis' decision posted on the Internet.


Threatening language

In a default proceeding, Administrative Law Judge Charlotte Davidson recommended termination of employment for a stock worker [Respondent] assigned to work in the kitchen at a juvenile detention center who used threatening language toward a supervisor. 

The Employer [Petitioner] alleged that Respondent threatened and used inappropriate language towards a fellow employee and engaged in behavior that threatened good order and discipline. The ALJ found that Respondent threatened his supervisor by stating that “if we was in the streets, you would get a headshot,” while waving a knife. 

In assessing penalty, the ALJ noted that Respondent’s threatening behavior occurred in a locked space while he was gesturing with a knife, the seriousness of Respondent’s threats, and Respondent’s failure to present any mitigation. 

Click HERE to access Judge Davidson's findings and recommendation posted on the Internet.