ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IS NOT USED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, IN THE SUMMARIES OF JUDICIAL AND QUASI-JUDICIAL DECISIONS PREPARED BY NYPPL

August 04, 2015

Alternative to personal service of a petition upon a respondent in an appeal to the Commissioner of Education may be authorized


Alternative to personal service of a petition upon a respondent in an appeal to the Commissioner of Education may be authorized
Decisions of the Commissioner, Decision #16798

One of the objections raised by the School District in this appeal submitted by Stan J. Ercolano to the Commissioner of Education challenging the election of certain members of the School Board to the Board was that the petition was served on one of the named respondents [Pierce] by mail rather than by personal service. 

Addressing this particular objection included among a number of procedural challenges advance by School Board in its efforts to have Ercolano’s appeal dismissed, the Commissioner noted that §275.8(d) of the Commissioner’s regulations provides, in pertinent part. That “If an appeal involves the validity of a school district meeting or election ... a copy of the petition must be served upon the trustee or board of trustees or board of education as the case may be, and upon each person whose right to hold office is disputed and such person must be joined as a respondent.” (emphasis in the Decision).

However, said the Commissioner, although §275.8(a) of the Commissioner’s regulations generally requires that the petition be personally served upon each named respondent,  §275.8(a) provides, in pertinent part that, “if a named respondent cannot be found upon diligent search, ... [service may be made] as otherwise directed by the commissioner.” 

The decision indicates that Ercolano had sent a fax to Education Department’s Office of Counsel requesting permission to effect alternate service by mail upon Pierce after he had “unsuccessfully attempting to effect personal service” upon Pierce at various different times and on different days.  The Office of Counsel sent Ercolano a letter granting him permission to serve Pierce by regular and certified mail, return receipt requested.  Ercolano then effected service, as approved, that same day.
 
The Commissioner said that it appears that Pierce “chose not to pick up the copy of the pleadings sent to her by certified mail” and found that service upon Pierce “was proper and made in compliance with the alternative service petitioner was authorized to use pursuant to §275.8(a) of the Commissioner’s regulations.”

The School District also argue that Ercolano “should have continued to attempt personal service” on Pierce even after the pleadings had been mailed to her by Ercolano as he was directed to do in Office of Councel’s approval letter.  However, affidavits of service submitted by Ercolano stated that an additional attempt to personally serve Pierce was made on the evening of June 16, 2011, but was unsuccessful.

The Commissioner ruled that in this instance “service was proper and [declined] to dismiss the appeal for failure to properly serve Pierce … and join her as a necessary party. 

The decision is posted on the Internet at:

August 03, 2015

Dismissed probationary teacher seeks damages for the employer’s alleged fraudulent inducement and breach of contract and for the union’s alleged breach of its duty of fair representation


Dismissed probationary teacher seeks damages for the employer’s alleged fraudulent inducement and breach of contract and for the union’s alleged breach of its duty of fair representation
2015 NY Slip Op 06331, Appellate Division, Second Department

The plaintiff [Probationer] commenced an action against the School District and certain named individuals [district defendants] and against the school district’s Teachers Association and New York State United Teachers [union defendants] .after her employment as a probationary teacher was terminated. Probationer’s amended complaint asserted causes of action to recover damages for the district defendant' alleged fraudulent inducement and breach of contract and a cause of action to recover damages for the union defendants' alleged breach of the duty of fair representation.

The Appellate Division ruled that Supreme Court properly granted the district defendants' cross motion to dismiss the amended complaint insofar as asserted against them. The court explained that a teacher's employment may be terminated during his or her probationary period for any reason, or no reason at all, unless the teacher establishes that his or her employment was terminated for a constitutionally impermissible purpose or in violation of a statutory proscription.

Here, said the court, the amended complaint failed to allege that Probationer’s employment was terminated for a constitutionally impermissible purpose or in violation of a statutory proscription. As Probationer was an at-will employee, whose employment could be terminated at any time during the probationary period, the Appellate Division said that “there can be no action alleging breach of contract, citing Havilland v Yonkers Public Schools, 21 AD3d 527.

In addition, the court commented that the amended complaint failed to establish that the Probationer reasonably relied upon the district defendants' alleged misrepresentations, which is an element necessary to the recovery of damages under a theory of fraudulent inducement.

Accordingly, the Appellate Division concluded that the amended complaint failed to state a cause of action against the district defendants.

Turning Supreme Court’s dismissal of the amended complaint insofar as asserted against the union defendants, the Appellate Division said that “Because the union defendants were unincorporated associations, and because the amended complaint failed to allege that the conduct complained of on the part of the union defendants was authorized or ratified by every one of their respective members, the amended complaint failed to state a cause of action against the union defendants.”

In Martin v Curran, 303 NY 276, the Court of Appeals held that a voluntary unincorporated association "has no existence independent of its members" and that "for better or worse, wisely or otherwise, the Legislature has limited . . . suits against association officers, whether for breaches of agreements or for tortious wrongs, to cases where the individual liability of every single member can be alleged and proven" it vacated the lower courts ruling. 

Although certain exceptions have been carved out from this general rule, the court said that one commentator has observed that, “although a claim of breach of the duty of fair representation may be brought either in court or before an appropriate agency (such as the Public Employment Relations Board), the reality in light of Martin is that most such claims must be brought before an agency to survive early dismissal," citing Rubenstein, Union Immunity From Suit in New York, 2 NYU Journal of Law & Business 641.

An abstract of the Rubenstein article is posted on the Internet at:

The Appellate Division’s decision is posted on the Internet at:

August 02, 2015

Justia ranks the popularity of 6,208 Blawgs in 74 subcategories


Justia ranks the popularity of 6,208 Blawgs in 74 subcategories
Source: http://blawgsearch.justia.com/topblawgs

Listed below are “the top 25 Blawgs” of the 6208 Law Blogs  reported by Justia for the week ending July 31, 2015. Blawgs are ranked based on the number of visits to the Blawg from the BlawgSearch search engine and directory listing pages. Click on the highlighted text in color to access the Blawg. 


Provides liberal coverage of crime-related political and injustice news.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 2

Covers mortgage fraud information, fraud schemes and indictments. By Rachel Dollar.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 3

Covers England and Walescase law, legislation, and legal news. From the Inner Temple Library.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 4

Covers mergers and acquisitions, investment banking, IPOs, private equity, hedge funds, venture capital and law. From The New York Times.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 5

Covers sex offender laws and cases.
Last Updated: July 5, 2015 - Rank this Week: 6

A legal tabloid that provides news and gossip about the profession's colorful personalities and powerful institutions, as well as original commentary on breaking legal developments.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 7

Includes news, cases and commentary on real estate and property law in New Yorkand nationwide. By Newman FerraraLLP.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 8

By Eugene Volokh, Dale Carpenter, David Kopel, David Bernstein, David Post, Erik Jaffe, Ilya Somin, Jim Lindgren, Jonathan Adler, Kevan Choset, Orin Kerr, Randy Barnett, Russell Korobkin, Sasha Volokh, Stuart Benjamin, Todd Zywicki & Tyler Cowen.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 9

Covers the Supreme Court of the United States. By Bloomberg Law.
Last Updated: July 30, 2015 - Rank this Week: 10

Covers legal news. From the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 11

Covers privacy, crime and security online. From Wired News.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 12

By University of Miamilaw professor Michael Froomkin. Covers civil liberties, the Internet, Guantanamo, Iraqattrocities, politics and more.
Last Updated: July 29, 2015 - Rank this Week: 13

Blogging resources, ideas and news for law firm bloggers. By Kevin O'Keefe.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 14

Covers Brazilian IT law. In Portuguese. By Alexandre Atheniense.
Last Updated: January 25, 2015 - Rank this Week: 15

Features notices of new Opinions and Orders from the Montana Supreme Court, library announcements, research tips, and Montanalegal news.
Last Updated: July 30, 2015 - Rank this Week: 16

Features law, marketing, Internet legal resources and technology news. By Sabrina I. Pacifici.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 17

Covers legal business news, analysis and intelligence. From The American Lawyer.
Last Updated: May 4, 2012 - Rank this Week: 18

Provides summary and commentary on selected court and administrative decisions and related matters affecting public employers and employees in New York State. By Harvey Randall, Esq.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 19

Features law-related calls for papers, conferences and workshops. From the Ohio State Moritz College of Law, University of Georgia School of Law, University of Pittsburgh School of Law and University of Washington School of Law.
Last Updated: July 19, 2015 - Rank this Week: 20

Covers federal criminal law topics such as identity theft, capital punishment, drug enforcement, environmental crimes, immigration, and military law. By Tom Withers.
Last Updated: July 2, 2014 - Rank this Week: 21

Covers research, studies, and court cases related to sex offender issues.
Last Updated: July 30, 2015 - Rank this Week: 22

Chronicles the high cost of our legal system.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 23

Covers food poisoning law. By Bill Marler.
Last Updated: July 31, 2015 - Rank this Week: 24

Covers fraud and forensic accounting, including tax fraud and the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. By Tracy Coenen.
Last Updated: July 22, 2015 - Rank this Week: 25
 

August 01, 2015

Selected reports and information issued by New York State's Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli issued during the week ending August 1, 2015


Selected reports and information issued by New York State's Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli issued during the week ending August 1, 2015
[Click on text highlighted in colorto access the full report]

Next in line for Michel-Lama Apartments were skipped over
Applicants who were next in line for coveted Mitchell-Lama apartments were skipped over for people farther down the waiting lists because of lax oversight and poor controls, an audit by New York State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli determined. The audit released uncovered other lapses, including managing agents for Mitchell-Lama buildings who let residents have apartments without the required approval from the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development as well as co-op owners renting out their apartments on Airbnb. http://www.osc.state.ny.us/audits/allaudits/093015/14n3.pdf

Vendor boosted fuel costs during Superstorm Sandy recovery
In the emergency response to Superstorm Sandy, the state Division of Military and Naval Affairs used a catering company which tacked on $20,000 in excessive costs, according to a report released by State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli. http://osc.state.ny.us/audits/allaudits/bseaudits/bse20150729.pdf

New Jersey woman guilty of the theft of more $162,000 from the New York State Employees’ Retirement System
New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli and Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman announced the guilty plea of Linda Miller, 57, of Englewood, New Jersey, over the theft of more than $162,000 in pension benefits from the New York State and Local Employees Retirement System. The defendant, Linda Miller, continued to cash her mother Josephine Miller’s retirement benefits until 2012, despite her mother’s death in 2006. Linda Miller pleaded guilty to 3rd degree Grand Larceny, a class D felony, in Albany County Court before the Honorable Thomas A. Breslin


State Contract and payment actions during the month of June 2015
State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli announced his office approved 1,887 contracts valued at $12.3 billion and approved nearly 1.3 million payments worth approximately $11.8 billion in June. His office also rejected 170 contracts and related transactions valued at $356 million and more than 2,000 payments valued at more than $7.3 million due to fraud, waste or other improprieties. http://www.osc.state.ny.us/press/releases/july15/072815.htm?utm_source=weeklynews220150802&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=072815arelease


DiNapoli released the audits of the following jurisdictions:

Village of Fultonville

Town of Livonia

CAUTION

Subsequent court and administrative rulings, or changes to laws, rules and regulations may have modified or clarified or vacated or reversed the decisions summarized here. Accordingly, these summaries should be Shepardized® or otherwise checked to make certain that the most recent information is being considered by the reader.
THE MATERIAL ON THIS WEBSITE IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY. AGAIN, CHANGES IN LAWS, RULES, REGULATIONS AND NEW COURT AND ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS MAY AFFECT THE ACCURACY OF THE INFORMATION PROVIDED IN THIS LAWBLOG. THE MATERIAL PRESENTED IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE AND THE USE OF ANY MATERIAL POSTED ON THIS WEBSITE, OR CORRESPONDENCE CONCERNING SUCH MATERIAL, DOES NOT CREATE AN ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP.
New York Public Personnel Law Blog Editor Harvey Randall served as Principal Attorney, New York State Department of Civil Service; Director of Personnel, SUNY Central Administration; Director of Research, Governor’s Office of Employee Relations; and Staff Judge Advocate General, New York Guard. Consistent with the Declaration of Principles jointly adopted by a Committee of the American Bar Association and a Committee of Publishers and Associations, the material posted to this blog is presented with the understanding that neither the publisher nor NYPPL and, or, its staff and contributors are providing legal advice to the reader and in the event legal or other expert assistance is needed, the reader is urged to seek such advice from a knowledgeable professional.
Copyright 2009-2024 - Public Employment Law Press. Email: nyppl@nycap.rr.com.