The New York State Workers' Compensation Board denied a claim for Workers' Compensation benefits as the result of the Claimant's failure to give a Central School District [Employer] timely written notice of the claimed injury*.
Claimant, a school bus driver for the self-insured Employer, allegedly sustained a work-related shoulder injury when Claimant attempted to open the rear emergency door on the bus she had been driving. Later, after seeking medical treatment and being scheduled for surgery to repair what turned out to be a torn rotator cuff, Claimant informed the Employer of the accident and sought workers' compensation benefits. Employer objected to the claim upon the ground that Claimant had not given timely written notice of the claim.
Following a hearing, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge [ALJ] agreed with Employer's decision and disallowed the claim. The Workers' Compensation Board [Board] sustained the ALJ's ruling and Claimant appealed.
The Appellate Division, citing Matter of Andino v Structural Preserv. Sys., 222 AD3d 1132 and other decisions, affirmed the Board's ruling, noting that §18 of the Workers' Compensation Law* requires that a claimant seeking workers' compensation benefits give written notice of the claim to his or her employer within 30 days of sustaining a compensable injury.
In the words of the Appellate Division, "A failure to give timely written notice may be excused by the Board if the claimant demonstrates that notice could not be given, that the employer or its agent had knowledge of the accident or that the employer was not prejudiced" and although the Board "is vested with discretion to excuse a lack of timely written notice, it is not required to do so even if one of those grounds has been proven".
Although Claimant testified that "she told one of the Employer's mechanics about the stuck door in February 2022, she did not notify the employer about the accident until September 2022 despite having ongoing shoulder pain". However the Appellate Division's decision noted the Board "correctly noted that [Claimant] telling a coworker about the stuck door was 'not . . . sufficient to meet the statutory requirements' of notice to the employer".
The Appellate Division's decision also pointed out that the Board found that Claimant's delay in seeking medical attention and reporting the incident called "the veracity of the claim into question and prevented the [employer] from securing a contemporaneous medical opinion" and, based thereon, she did not demonstrate a lack of prejudice to the employer from the failure to provide timely notice."
* An employer is obliged to file a first report of injury with the Board "[o]n or before the 18th day after the disability event or within 10 days after the employer has knowledge of the disability event, whichever period is the greater". The report filed by the Employer in October 2022 stated that it had knowledge of Claimant's injury in February 2022 but subsequently the Employer advised the Board that "it was not notified of [Claimant's] injury until October 2022" and Claimant acknowledged that she did not notify the Employer of the event "until September 2022 at the earliest".
Click HERE to access the Appellate Division's decision posted on the Internet.