ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE [AI] IS NOT USED IN COMPOSING NYPPL SUMMARIES OF JUDICIAL AND QUASI-JUDICIAL DECISIONS.

Nov 19, 2026

Petitioner sued the New York City Department of Education pursuant New York State's Freedom of Information Law to compel it to disclose certain records

In this proceeding pursuant to CPLR Article 78 to compel disclosure of certain records pursuant to New York State's Freedom of Information Law, (Public Officers Law Article 6), [FOIL], Petitioner appeals from a judgment of a Supreme Court which denied those branches of the petition which were to compel the production of records sought in "part 3(b)" of the Petitioner's FOIL request and for an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs. 

The Appellate Division modified the Supreme Court's ruling, on the law, by deleting the provision thereof denying that branch of the petition which was to compel the production of records sought in part 3(b) of the Petitioner's FOIL request and, in effect, dismissing that portion of the proceeding, and substituting therefor a provision granting that branch of the petition; as so modified, the judgment affirmed the Supreme Court's decision insofar as appealed from, without costs or disbursements.
ted  t
Petitioner's FOIL request asked New York City Department of Education [DOE] to provide it with certain records. As relevant to this appeal, the Petitioner sought "[r]ecords which describe implications of Wisconsin v. Jonas Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972) with regard to standards for compulsory education, including: ... [g]uidelines, memoranda, and other records which outline minimum requirements for education in nonpublic schools."

The DOE responded to Plaintiff's FOIL request, identifying certain requests for which no responsive documents could be located, provided certain documents in response to other requests and withheld certain records on the ground that Plaintiff had requested  "legal conclusions". Petitioner administratively appealed DOE's decision, which decision DOE  sustained, explaining that Plaintiff "sought a legal conclusion and that the records were not reasonably described".

The Petitioner commenced the instant proceeding pursuant to CPLR Article 78 to compel production of, among other records, those sought in part 3(b) of its FOIL request, and for an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs.

Supreme Court granted the petition "as to a single document, with redactions", but, as relevant to the instant appeal, denied those branches of the petition which [a] compelled  production of the records sought in part 3(b) of the FOIL request and [b] for an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs and, in effect, dismissed those portions of the Petitioner's proceeding. Petitioner appealed the Supreme Court's ruling.

Set out below are the Appellate Division rulings addressing the Petitioner's appeal involving the Supreme Court's decision:

1. "FOIL imposes a broad duty on government to make its records available to the public" and "Unless otherwise specifically exempted, all records of a public agency are presumptively open to public inspection and copying". Further, " The limited categories of records which may be withheld are enumerated in FOIL [and] Consistent with the policy of broad public access, the exemptions are to be narrowly construed, and the burden rests on the agency to demonstrate that the requested material qualifies for exemption".

2. "Contrary to the DOE's contention, there is no categorical exemption for "legal conclusions" and the DOE's reliance on certain advisory opinions in which the request failed to seek records already in existence is misplaced [as] Public Officers Law §89(3)(a) provides in relevant part that '[n]othing in this article shall be construed to require any entity to prepare any record not possessed or maintained by such entity.' Thus, an agency has no obligation to create a new record or to accommodate a request to compile data in a particular format when the agency does not maintain the records in such a manner. Here, part 3(b) of the FOIL request sought particular "[r]ecords which describe implications of Wisconsin v. Jonas Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972) with regard to standards for compulsory education" (emphasis added). 

3. Contrary to the DOE's contention, the request does not seek legal conclusions, nor would it require the DOE to conduct legal analysis of its records. The DOE did not contend that it has no records which facially describe implications of Yoder with regard to the standards for compulsory education. Accordingly, to the extent that such records exist, the DOE may not withhold them on the ground that they involve a legal conclusion".

4. "The DOE also failed to sustain its burden of proving that the request was not reasonably described. To trigger a government agency's obligation to produce records under [FOIL], the person seeking the records must submit to the agency a written request in which the records sought are 'reasonably described' (Public Officers Law §89[3][a]). An agency, having received such a request for records maintained electronically, must retrieve the records if it has the ability to do so 'with reasonable effort' [citing] (Matter of Wagner v New York City Dept. of Educ., 45 NY3d 93, 95). The requirement that requested records be reasonably described exists to ensure that the responding agency has the ability to locate the records sought" [and] "Whether the DOE can retrieve those documents with reasonable effort is a separate question".

5. "Contrary to the DOE's contention, the subject request was reasonably described. The request was sufficiently detailed to enable the DOE to understand what documents the petitioner seeks and to determine whether the DOE possesses any such records" [case citations omitted].

6. Contrary to the "Petitioner's contention, 'it did not substantially prevail in the proceeding, as the bulk of its petition was denied'. Accordingly, it is not entitled to an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs [See Public Officers Law §89[4][c]" [case citations omitted].

Click HERE to access the Appellate Division's decision posted on the Internet.

Nov 18, 2026

Retirement System's Member's application seeking refund of certain contributions made to the New York State and Local Retirement System denied

Supreme Court dismissed Plaintiff's CPLR Article 78 application seeking review of a determination by the New York State Comptroller denying Plaintiff's application for a refund of certain pension contributions he had made to the New York State and Local Retirement System [NYSLRS]. Plaintiff appealed the Supreme Court's decision.

The Appellate Division's decision, set out below, sustained the Supreme Court's ruling, holding although the "petitioner also presents a reasonable view of the statutory language, we are precluded from substituting our judgement for that of the agency where the agency's own interpretation is also reasonable". 

In the Matter of Michael Pasinkoff, Appellant,

v

New York State and Local Retirement System, Respondent.

Nov 17, 2026

Probationary employee challenged the termination of his employment after being found to have failed to satisfactorily complete his probationary period

The New York City Department of Education [DOE] determined that the Plaintiff had failed to satisfactorily complete his probationary period of his employment with DOE and terminated his probationary employment as an educator. 

Plaintiff had commenced probationary employment as a special education teacher with DOE. Subsequently Plaintiff became the subject of an investigation into his alleged use of excessive force in restraining a student. Prior to the end of Plaintiff's probationary period DOE determined that Plaintiff had failed to satisfactorily complete his probationary period and terminated his employment effective September 1, 2022. 

Plaintiff then commenced the instant proceeding pursuant to CPLR Article 78 seeking:

(a) judicial review of DOE's determination terminating his probationary employment;

(b) his reinstatement as a tenured teacher with DOE; and 

(c) an award of back pay and benefits. 

Supreme Court denied Plaintiff's petition and dismissed the proceeding whereupon Plaintiff appeal the Supreme Court's ruling. The Appellate Division affirmed the Supreme Court's decision, opining that DOE's determination denying the Plaintiff certification of having satisfactorily completed his probationary and terminating his employment "was not arbitrary and capricious." 

The Appellate Division's decision noted that DOE may deny tenure to a probationary teacher "without a hearing and without stating any reasons for its action absent a showing that the termination was for a constitutionally impermissible purpose, violative of a statute, or done in bad faith"*. Further, the Appellate Division observed that Plaintiff's "conclusory and unsubstantiated assertions were not sufficient to meet his burden of showing that the DOE acted in bad faith or for illegal reasons".

In addition, the Appellate Division opined that Plaintiff had failed to establish his entitlement to a name-clearing hearing, citing Matter of Swinton v Safir, 93 NY2d 758  and other court decisions.

Nota Bene: 

1. In York v McGuire, 63 NY2d 760, the Court of Appeals held that “After completing his or her minimum period of probation and prior to completing his or her maximum period of probation, a probationary employee can be dismissed without a hearing and without a statement of reasons, as long as there is no proof that the dismissal was done for a constitutionally impermissible purpose, or in violation of statutory or decisional law, or the decision was made in bad faith.”

2. In Mendez v Valenti, 101 AD2d 612, the Appellate Division ruled that as long as the termination of a probationer is effected within a reasonable time after the end of the probationer's maximum period of probation, such as set to coincide with the end of the next payroll period, the courts will not deem the individual to have obtained tenure by estoppel because of the individual's continuation on the payroll following the last day of the individual's probationary period.

ClicK HERE to access the Appellate Division's decision in the instant proceeding posted on the Internet.



Nov 16, 2026

Absent a waiver by the New York State Workers' Compensation Board, timely written notice of the injury to the employer is required to perfect a claim for Workers Compensation benefits

The New York State Workers' Compensation Board denied a claim for Workers' Compensation benefits as the result of the Claimant's failure to give a Central School District [Employer] timely written notice of the claimed injury*.

Claimant, a school bus driver for the self-insured Employer, allegedly sustained a work-related shoulder injury when Claimant attempted to open the rear emergency door on the bus she had been driving. Later, after seeking medical treatment and being scheduled for surgery to repair what turned out to be a torn rotator cuff, Claimant informed the Employer of the accident and sought workers' compensation benefits. Employer objected to the claim upon the ground that Claimant had not given timely written notice of the claim.

Following a hearing, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge [ALJ] agreed with Employer's decision and disallowed the claim. The Workers' Compensation Board [Board] sustained the ALJ's ruling and Claimant appealed.

The Appellate Division, citing Matter of Andino v Structural Preserv. Sys., 222 AD3d 1132 and other decisions, affirmed the Board's ruling, noting that §18 of the Workers' Compensation Law* requires that a claimant seeking workers' compensation benefits give written notice of the claim to his or her employer within 30 days of sustaining a compensable injury.

In the words of the Appellate Division, "A failure to give timely written notice may be excused by the Board if the claimant demonstrates that notice could not be given, that the employer or its agent had knowledge of the accident or that the employer was not prejudiced" and although the Board "is vested with discretion to excuse a lack of timely written notice, it is not required to do so even if one of those grounds has been proven".

Although Claimant testified that "she told one of the Employer's mechanics about the stuck door in February 2022, she did not notify the employer about the accident until September 2022 despite having ongoing shoulder pain". However the Appellate Division's decision noted the Board "correctly noted that [Claimant] telling a coworker about the stuck door was 'not . . . sufficient to meet the statutory requirements' of notice to the employer".

The Appellate Division's decision also pointed out that the Board found that Claimant's delay in seeking medical attention and reporting the incident called "the veracity of the claim into question and prevented the [employer] from securing a contemporaneous medical opinion" and, based thereon, she did not demonstrate a lack of prejudice to the employer from the failure to provide timely notice."

* An employer is obliged to file a first report of injury with the Board "[o]n or before the 18th day after the disability event or within 10 days after the employer has knowledge of the disability event, whichever period is the greater". The report filed by the Employer in October 2022 stated that it had knowledge of Claimant's injury in February 2022 but subsequently the Employer advised the Board that "it was not notified of [Claimant's] injury until October 2022" and Claimant acknowledged that she did not notify the Employer of the event "until September 2022 at the earliest".


Click HERE to access the Appellate Division's decision posted on the Internet. 


Nov 14, 2026

Selected items posted on the Internet during the week ending November 13, 2026

THE ENFORCERS BY POLITICO: State attorneys general are among the most consequential officials in American government — and among the least covered. POLITICO will track what AGs are targeting, where they’re headed next and what it means for the companies and causes in their sights. Pro subscribers will have access as part of their plans, and everyone else can preview it starting tomorrow. Sign up here.

The Stories Behind Exceptional Public Service Governing CEO Cathilea Robinett explores purpose, persistence, and leadership with the 2026 Public Officials of the Year. Listen & Subscribe

More than one-in-ten working-age Americans didn’t have health coverage in 2026, according to a new survey. Many who did still deferred care because of cost. Read More

How One Pennsylvania County Is Putting Brownfields Funding to Work Hear Commissioner Josh Zucal discuss EPA-funded site assessments and community reuse planning. Watch the webinar replay

A New Era for Justice Information Sharing This paper explores how cloud, AI and other technological advancements are creating new opportunities for secure justice information sharing. DOWNLOAD

New Officials, New Priorities. Build Relationships Early. Leaders share their priorities in public. Show up with solutions. Read the post-election playbook

Big Ideas. Bold Leaders. The Future of Gov Tech. Candid conversations with the builders, backers, and leaders shaping what's next in government technology. Watch Now

Build Trust in AI Without Sacrificing Performance Explore how a unified approach to AI observability can help organizations improve reliability, reduce operational risks, and scale AI with confidence. DOWNLOAD

Communications Resiliency for the Modern Government Workforce Agencies need to support employees wherever they work and ensure services remain available during disruptions. This paper explains how agencies can consolidate calling, messaging and collaboration on a single platform to strengthen mobility and continuity of operations. DOWNLOAD

HOW TO REDUCE CYBERATTACK DWELL TIME? Discover Cyberattack Artifacts with CPTRAM Zero-Cost Endpoint Review for all Windows Endpoints Receive your free analysis today


Nov 13, 2026

The date of the lawful service of the final administrative disciplinary decision triggers the running of the statute of limitations to appeal the administrative decision

Supreme Court denied Plaintiff's CPLR Article 78 petition seeking to annul the New York City Transit Authority's [Respondent] decision, rejecting Plaintiff's contention that he was entitled to an exemption from the New York City Transit Authority internal disciplinary process and that the disciplinary charges filed against him should have been considered at a  disciplinary hearing held pursuant to Civil Service Law §75. 

The Appellate Division unanimously affirmed the Supreme Court's ruling.

The Appellate Division explained that Respondent's January 31, 2024, decision denying Petitioner's appeal of his disciplinary suspension was final and binding and "put the [Petitioner] on notice that all administrative appeals have been exhausted".  

Noting that Plaintiff commenced the instant Article 78 proceeding on January 30, 2025, nearly one year after the Respondent's "final determination", the Appellate Division said that Supreme Court properly dismissed the proceeding as time barred, pointing out that contrary to Plaintiff's contention, "there was nothing contained in the January 31, 2024 determination that created ambiguity or the impression of nonfinality". 

Click HERE to access the Appellate Division's decision posted on the Internet.


Nov 12, 2026

Summaries of recent decisions posted on the Internet by the New York City Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings [OATH]

Worker Protection Administrative Law Judge [ALJ] held that the Employee should be awarded relief and civil penalties and recommended that the amounts to be awarded should consist of $3,000 as "employee relief" and $3,550 in civil penalties should be paid by the Employer for violating the Earned Safe and Sick Time Act. Click HERE to access Judge Turilli's decision and recommendation posted on the Internet.

Dismissal of discilipinary charge recommended ALJ Joycelyn McGeachy-Kuls recommended dismissal of a disciplinary charge filed against an Eligibility Specialist after Employer failed to prove that Employee was excessively absent or that the Employee's absences negatively impacted her department. Click HERE to access Judge McGeachy-Kuls decision and recommendation posted on the Internet.





Editor in Chief Harvey Randall served as Director of Personnel, State University of New York Central Administration; Director of Research, Governor's Office of Employee Relations; Principal Attorney, Counsel's Office, New York State Department of Civil Service; and Colonel, JAG, Command Headquarters, New York Guard. Consistent with the Declaration of Principles jointly adopted by a Committee of the American Bar Association and a Committee of Publishers and Associations, the material posted to this blog is presented with the understanding that neither the publisher nor NYPPL and, or, its staff and contributors are providing legal advice to the reader and in the event legal or other expert assistance is needed, the reader is urged to seek such advice from a knowledgeable professional.

CAUTION

Subsequent court and administrative rulings, or changes to laws, rules and regulations may have modified or clarified or vacated or reversed the information and, or, decisions summarized in NYPPL. For example, New York State Department of Civil Service's Advisory Memorandum 24-08 reflects changes required as the result of certain amendments to §72 of the New York State Civil Service Law to take effect January 1, 2025 [See Chapter 306 of the Laws of 2024]. Advisory Memorandum 24-08 in PDF format is posted on the Internet at https://www.cs.ny.gov/ssd/pdf/AM24-08Combined.pdf. Accordingly, the information and case summaries should be Shepardized® or otherwise checked to make certain that the most recent information is being considered by the reader.
THE MATERIAL ON THIS WEBSITE IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY. AGAIN, CHANGES IN LAWS, RULES, REGULATIONS AND NEW COURT AND ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS MAY AFFECT THE ACCURACY OF THE INFORMATION PROVIDED IN THIS LAWBLOG. THE MATERIAL PRESENTED IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE AND THE USE OF ANY MATERIAL POSTED ON THIS WEBSITE, OR CORRESPONDENCE CONCERNING SUCH MATERIAL, DOES NOT CREATE AN ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP.
New York Public Personnel Law. Email: publications@nycap.rr.com