In this proceeding pursuant to CPLR Article 78 to compel disclosure of certain records pursuant to New York State's Freedom of Information Law, (Public Officers Law Article 6), [FOIL], Petitioner appeals from a judgment of a Supreme Court which denied those branches of the petition which were to compel the production of records sought in "part 3(b)" of the Petitioner's FOIL request and for an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs.
The Appellate Division modified the Supreme Court's ruling, on the law, by deleting the provision thereof denying that branch of the petition which was to compel the production of records sought in part 3(b) of the Petitioner's FOIL request and, in effect, dismissing that portion of the proceeding, and substituting therefor a provision granting that branch of the petition; as so modified, the judgment affirmed the Supreme Court's decision insofar as appealed from, without costs or disbursements.
ted t
Petitioner's FOIL request asked New York City Department of Education [DOE] to provide it with certain records. As relevant to this appeal, the Petitioner sought "[r]ecords which describe implications of Wisconsin v. Jonas Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972) with regard to standards for compulsory education, including: ... [g]uidelines, memoranda, and other records which outline minimum requirements for education in nonpublic schools."
The DOE responded to Plaintiff's FOIL request, identifying certain requests for which no responsive documents could be located, provided certain documents in response to other requests and withheld certain records on the ground that Plaintiff had requested "legal conclusions". Petitioner administratively appealed DOE's decision, which decision DOE sustained, explaining that Plaintiff "sought a legal conclusion and that the records were not reasonably described".
The Petitioner commenced the instant proceeding pursuant to CPLR Article 78 to compel production of, among other records, those sought in part 3(b) of its FOIL request, and for an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs.
Supreme Court granted the petition "as to a single document, with redactions", but, as relevant to the instant appeal, denied those branches of the petition which [a] compelled production of the records sought in part 3(b) of the FOIL request and [b] for an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs and, in effect, dismissed those portions of the Petitioner's proceeding. Petitioner appealed the Supreme Court's ruling.
Set out below are the Appellate Division rulings addressing the Petitioner's appeal involving the Supreme Court's decision:
1. "FOIL imposes a broad duty on government to make its records available to the public" and "Unless otherwise specifically exempted, all records of a public agency are presumptively open to public inspection and copying". Further, " The limited categories of records which may be withheld are enumerated in FOIL [and] Consistent with the policy of broad public access, the exemptions are to be narrowly construed, and the burden rests on the agency to demonstrate that the requested material qualifies for exemption".
2. "Contrary to the DOE's contention, there is no categorical exemption for "legal conclusions" and the DOE's reliance on certain advisory opinions in which the request failed to seek records already in existence is misplaced [as] Public Officers Law §89(3)(a) provides in relevant part that '[n]othing in this article shall be construed to require any entity to prepare any record not possessed or maintained by such entity.' Thus, an agency has no obligation to create a new record or to accommodate a request to compile data in a particular format when the agency does not maintain the records in such a manner. Here, part 3(b) of the FOIL request sought particular "[r]ecords which describe implications of Wisconsin v. Jonas Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972) with regard to standards for compulsory education" (emphasis added).
3. Contrary to the DOE's contention, the request does not seek legal conclusions, nor would it require the DOE to conduct legal analysis of its records. The DOE did not contend that it has no records which facially describe implications of Yoder with regard to the standards for compulsory education. Accordingly, to the extent that such records exist, the DOE may not withhold them on the ground that they involve a legal conclusion".
4. "The DOE also failed to sustain its burden of proving that the request was not reasonably described. To trigger a government agency's obligation to produce records under [FOIL], the person seeking the records must submit to the agency a written request in which the records sought are 'reasonably described' (Public Officers Law §89[3][a]). An agency, having received such a request for records maintained electronically, must retrieve the records if it has the ability to do so 'with reasonable effort' [citing] (Matter of Wagner v New York City Dept. of Educ., 45 NY3d 93, 95). The requirement that requested records be reasonably described exists to ensure that the responding agency has the ability to locate the records sought" [and] "Whether the DOE can retrieve those documents with reasonable effort is a separate question".
5. "Contrary to the DOE's contention, the subject request was reasonably described. The request was sufficiently detailed to enable the DOE to understand what documents the petitioner seeks and to determine whether the DOE possesses any such records" [case citations omitted].
6. Contrary to the "Petitioner's contention, 'it did not substantially prevail in the proceeding, as the bulk of its petition was denied'. Accordingly, it is not entitled to an award of attorney's fees and litigation costs [See Public Officers Law §89[4][c]" [case citations omitted].
Click HERE to access the Appellate Division's decision posted on the Internet.